I often get many questions and people email me photos of their chrysalides that they are not sure about. I thought I would share my knowledge and experience with chrysalides with everyone.  These chrysalides below are all healthy, you will notice the wings of the monarch a couple of days before emergence begins. It just so happens I must take most of my photos after the rain has stopped, this is not the chrysalis sweating!

Untitled design (21)

The rule of thumb is that it shouldn’t be black for more than 3 days, it’s likely the monarch inside the chrysalis has a bacteria or disease, or a predator has laid its eggs inside and killed the chrysalis.  If the chrysalis has been very dark for at least five days, and you cannot see the orange wings through the transparent casing, the monarch butterfly inside is dead, and it will then dry up. Dispose of your bad chrysalis to avoid disease spreading. 

Untitled design (29)

When the time comes to pupate, the caterpillars will find a sheltered, safe spot in which to transform into an adult and form their chrysalis (hard green case) which will protect them through this process. If your caterpillars are outside, they will usually hang from the roof of the cage or branch and turn into a chrysalis. They should be left in this position until the monarch emerges. Make sure your chrysalis is out of direct sunlight. The word ‘chrysalis’ comes from the Greek word for gold, and you can see an amazing line of gold dots around the top once the chrysalis is fully formed. This is the start of the process of metamorphosis. Chrysalises cannot fly, bite, sting, or run away if discovered by a predator, they are completely helpless.  One of the main reasons the chrysalis is green is to blend in with the surrounding environment.

What is the difference between a chrysalis and a cocoon?

This question will come up a lot and people do get confused until they read about it.  The chrysalis is a butterfly pupa, which is a hard case that appears after the caterpillar’s final shedding of its skin. It attaches to a leaf via a silk pad spun by the caterpillar.  A cocoon is just a constructed silk casing used by moths and certain other types of insects. We have all read “the hungry caterpillar” book it states a cocoon, not a chrysalis which is wrong but that caterpillar also eats ice cream and strawberry. It’s not a guidebook, just a story.

Taking care of your chrysalises

Your chrysalis doesn’t need food or water. If your swan plants are inside then an occasional misting of the swan plant will help keep the environment humid, which is necessary for a healthy chrysalis.  Caterpillars will stop eating and start crawling away from their host plant trying to find the safest place to form a chrysalis, mainly hiding under other plants in the garden. They like part shade as the chrysalis sometimes burns and dries up in the sun’s rays in peak summer.  I still get blown away by the way gold dots appear around the top of a healthy chrysalis. I have found caterpillars halfway down my driveway, many meters away from their original home, that I have had to rescue and put safely on a suitable plant before someone steps on them.

In summer, the metamorphosis from caterpillar to monarch butterfly (i.e. the chrysalis stage), takes up to two weeks. Late forming monarch butterflies will stay in their chrysalis throughout winter, but I have experienced monarchs emerging from this state after 10-12 weeks as healthy adult butterflies. Remember that your diapausing chrysalises are still alive.  If the chrysalis has fallen off a stick, you can hang it by placing a dot of hot glue on a piece of paper and then placing the tip of the chrysalis in the slightly cooled (but still liquid) hot glue. Hold the chrysalis on the paper for a few seconds to allow the glue to go hard.  I have also tied cotton around the cremaster which is the black hook that hangs to their silk matt and then hung this up somewhere safe with Sellotape.

A chrysalis will become darker and then look transparent a couple of days before the monarch butterfly is ready to hatch. Keep a careful watch, as it only takes a few minutes for a monarch to emerge from its chrysalis! In some cases, it can take up to 45 minutes, but these monarchs are likely to have irregularities or diseases and will be weak. 

Want to know more about taking care of vital pollinators and would like to purchase my book that has all you need to know about creating a beautiful butterfly garden and raising healthy monarch butterflies go purchase my excellent resource book.

A Guide On Monarch Butterflies

USA residents please purchase via Amazon only $11.58 USD.


21 thoughts on “Chrysalides: The Good and the Bad

  1. thank you.Having trouble starting milkweed in Sacramento. Do Monarchs come this far east?

    1. Very helpful, thanks. We’ve got one monarch Crysalis that looks healthy but hasn’t hatched in a few weeks. If it over winters in MN and if it hatched too early what do I feed it until spring?

      1. Thanks for reaching out!! Winter monarchs stay in their chrysalis longer than the summer months. Just place the monarch on a flower outside during the winter, he/she knows where to fly they have been doing this for 100’s of years. Maria

  2. Hi I have a question I just started to plant milkweed in Torrance California and I found one monarch caterpillar and it did make a pupa but it is black at the top and I noticed a small hole in the top and I am worried a little critter got in there and ate the poor thing.I go out every day to see if the crysalis is getting darker all the way down but do you think it has been eaten.? Is it normal to have a hole in the top right? Thanks Cindy

    1. Hello Cindy, lovely to hear from you. Sounds like another insect or bug has made the hole, its nature Im afraid over here in New Zealand wasps like to suck the inside of the chrysalis. If this happens a lot bring the chrysalis inside until the monarch emerges, just pull gently on the silk around the top of the black hook (cremester).

  3. I have successfully raised and released five monarchs so far, and was very distressed to see my sixth one apparently I purchased bad milkweed? My cat turned black just before pupating I was afraid he had OE disease, but he did end up pupating and he’s hanging now. I for the first time see gooey stuff in the bottom and two antennas and there’s a clear spot I hope he’s not diseased. He pupated November 18th. Thank you for all your information that has kept me very supportive this whole time

    1. Thanks so much it;s a pleasure sharing. As when I started out I was doing so many things wrong as I didn’t have the knowledge available. Unfortunately our caterpillars are very sensitive to new plants as new plants maybe more toxic than others and can make them sick. Also in future perhaps wash your plants and give to your caterpillars after a couples of days. This makes sure that any sprays have washed off that could potentially harm the caterpillars.

  4. I live in Florida and my monarch chrysalises did not hatch in the expected time frame. We did have a cold snap where it was in the 50s and 60s for a few days. They are still their beautiful greenish color with the gold flex they have not changed color. Do you think they are still viable

    1. Yes totally your right, weather effects the total time the caterpillar is in the chrysalis. Early spring here in Christchurch was nearly a month before the monarch butterfly emerged. Try and keep it covered and out of freezing cold winds and frost.

  5. Hi there. I have a bunch of chrysalis that have turned black and nothing emerged….do they need alot of sun ? It is under our deck so they get light but not sun. Wondering if I should move the others to a brighter location

    1. Sorry I have just this. Chrysalisaides should only be black/transparent for one or two days. The butterfly may have died inside or got bacteria in it. They need a little warmth as the colder it take longer it is to emerge into a butterfly.

  6. Hi I just found a chrysalis that I missed and it is black. I have 2 others and 1 is still green and the other is almost transparent I’m just wondering if something is wrong with the hidden one. Also if it is dead or dying will the chrysalis be soft and mushy or hard still? Thank you

  7. I was so excited to find your page. A friend and I just found a beautiful green.. what we thought was a cocoon…but now know is a chrysalis for a monarch butterfly. We were excited about the gold dots and and even more excited know that’s a sign it’s transforming. Thank you. 🦋

  8. My chrysalis is black. Its been black for 2 days. I’ve had 4 other ones that died before their chrysalis stage. It might of been for the milk weed. This is the only caterpillar that is in a chrysalis.

  9. Hello! I have a chrysalis in my future, and the caterpillar has chosen the bottom face of my blink doorbell. Temps are dropping here: 40F overnight and 60F during the day. Will this beauty overwinter in the chrysalis and should I move it to protect it?

  10. liltexasbutterfly@gmail.com
    you commented – Chrysalis been very dark for at least five days, and you cannot see the orange wings through the transparent casing, the monarch butterfly inside is dead,

    I am an amateur, but one of mine was dark from beginning I and worried,. First butterfly emerged then the second one it had been dark 7 days.

    So occasionally it may be ok I suppose, as a precaution you can separate

  11. Thank you. I found this page after finding a chrysalis stuck to my mothers outdoor railing. It’s been dark for awhile so I don’t think it’s alive. But I’ve looked for all this information and you’ve said it best. 🙂

  12. I have two chrysalis that look a little green but they have been in their chrysalis for 3 weeks. Im in Central Oregon. We have just grown milkweed for the last 5 years and its the first time we had monarch caterpillars. We put the chrysalis in a mesh cage in the green house when the temps dipped to 45 deg f. Will they just overwinter at this point or are they dead? Thank you so much!

    1. Hello,
      The length of which they stay in the chrysalis towards winter will extended a week or so due to temp. Do your chrysaliades have any markings or do they look clean and healthy??? If it darkens brownish the chrysalis may have been infected.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.